a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

Hegseth is a propaganda flop. Don’t let Congress throw him a lifeline

8 hours 4 minutes ago

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is obsessed with controlling the narrative. His censorship and propaganda efforts are myriad: lashing out over photographs of himself he doesn’t like, barring reporters from the Pentagon who don’t sign away their First Amendment rights, forcing suspected leakers to take ineffective polygraph tests, undermining the independence of military newspaper Stars and Stripes, and secretly compensating social media influencers who praise him.

But as Guardian columnist Margaret Sullivan recently noted, Hegseth is failing as a propagandist. The Iran war is deeply unpopular, and his approval numbers are far lower than whatever testosterone level he and his insecurities deem unworthy of military service.

Still, Hegseth’s inability to sell the public on alternative facts doesn’t mean Americans are uniquely resistant to spin. It only means Hegseth can’t control the information ecosystem, no matter how many reporters he bans from news conferences. But that could change if politicians of both parties don’t stop supporting measures that undermine journalists and whistleblowers.

Journalists in the U.S. don’t need government permission to report — for now. But there are some things they do need.

Sources willing to come forward.

News outlets that aren’t vulnerable to reliance on the government. (The attacks on Stars and Stripes and other outlets that get federal funding show the limits of statutory guarantees of independence).

And an open internet where information can travel, notwithstanding private actors’ efforts to censor some corners.

When these conditions exist, journalists who turn in their press passes rather than sign loyalty pledges can find scoops in plenty of other ways, most of which would be far more difficult, if not impossible, absent the independent media and open internet.

Hegseth can’t sell the public on alternative facts because he can’t control the information ecosystem.

Officials in other countries without these ingredients have succeeded in pushing propaganda where Hegseth and the rest of the Trump administration have failed, and it’s not because those countries have less courageous journalists, a more gullible public, or more likable censors.

In Russia, independent outlets not controlled by loyal oligarchs have been forced to shut down or relocate abroad. Those who stay face prosecution for even calling the war in Ukraine a war. Many social media companies have been shut down, and Russia has started blocking VPNs that its citizens were using to evade the bans.

By contrast, the Trump administration’s efforts to relabel the war in Iran as anything but have been met with mockery, and anyone with an internet connection can get in on the joke.

In North Korea and Eritrea, the two lowest-ranking countries in Reporters Without Borders’ global press freedom index this year, there are no local journalists to blow the whistle to because reporting anything but authorized propaganda is a crime, punishable by imprisonment in horrid conditions or labor camps.

Those who oppose Trumpian censorship presumably appreciate that the conditions that blunt its impact exist here. And yet, support across both political parties in the U.S. remains strong for crackdowns on government leaks, and increased restrictions and surveillance of the internet.

Even as leaks enable countless important news stories about the administration — on immigration enforcement, the war in Iran, or the fiasco involving Trump’s unsafe Qatari jet — few politicians are standing up for whistleblowers who speak to the press.

We haven’t heard any mea culpas from politicians who supported prosecuting WikiLeaks publisher Julian Assange under the Espionage Act, even after the Trump administration cited Assange’s case to justify raiding the home of a Washington Post reporter in January, seizing terabytes of data.

Even as leaks enable countless important news stories about the administration, few politicians are standing up for whistleblowers.

In fact, last year, despite Trump threatening journalists and sources throughout his campaign, Democratic Sen. Mark Warner made calling whistleblower and Freedom of the Press (FPF) board member Ed Snowden a “traitor” into a litmus test for service in government. Warner hasn’t changed his tune since.

Similarly, lawmakers from both parties have shown a disturbing willingness to support initiatives to make the internet far less free.

Both Democrats and Republicans have cheered legislation that would require adults to submit to invasive age verification in order to read news online, as well as praised the recent legal settlement by Meta that will likely impose similar requirements across a swath of social media companies.

These requirements destroy the anonymity that people rely on to speak, read, and watch freely online. In an era where the feds may show up at your door over what you read, and tech companies may out you for criticizing the government, online anonymity is vital.

Similarly, proposals to repeal or gut Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act to make platforms legally responsible for user content — supported by some politicians from both parties — would do little to stem the tide of lawful but awful online posts. What it would do is push platforms to remove anything that upsets the powerful rather than invest in legal review of an infinite number of posts.

If you don’t like how the government cajoles tech companies into taking down users’ posts that displease it today (or yesterday), this problem will be far worse if platforms are unprotected from civil liability.

Congress should be focused on passing laws that safeguard First Amendment freedoms, rather than supporting measures that will allow Hegseth and his colleagues in the Trump administration to stamp out independent journalism like their authoritarian idols abroad.

Congress should be focused on passing laws that safeguard First Amendment freedoms.

It should pass The Daniel Ellsberg Press Freedom and Whistleblower Act, named after the famed Pentagon Papers leaker and FPF co-founder, which would increase protections for those who expose government wrongdoing.

And it should pass The Privacy Protection Updates Act, which would help put a stop to government raids on reporters.

It should also pass The Subpoena Abuse Prevention Act to rein in administrative subpoenas targeting journalists.

And, finally, it should pass the PRESS Act to stop the government from compelling reporters and tech companies to out whistleblowers.

These are some of the bills that you can urge your lawmakers to support. Otherwise, the consequences for the free press may be far uglier than any bad Hegseth hair day captured by news photographers at the Pentagon.

Seth Stern

Trump’s Canadian trade war stirs up trouble for Republican candidates

8 hours 43 minutes ago
President Donald Trump’s escalating trade war with Canada is creating headaches for Republicans ahead of November’s midterms as high prices remain a top concern among voters. Responding to Trump’s increased tariffs, Canadian officials have said they’re deliberately targeting goods from states where there are close elections. And GOP candidates in Kansas, Maine and Ohio among […]
Kevin Hardy

Automakers Pressure Congress To Ban Chinese EVs To ‘Protect Privacy’

9 hours 4 minutes ago
If you enjoy badly written bipartisan protectionist tech legislation designed primarily to coddle giant U.S. companies under the xenophobia-tinged breathless pretense of privacy and national security, you are really going to enjoy the next twelve to twenty-four months. While the U.S. drowns in corrupt kakistocracy, the Chinese are making significant market inroads in everything from […]
Karl Bode

States sue feds over endangered species rollbacks

9 hours 43 minutes ago
A coalition of state attorneys general filed a pair of lawsuits Wednesday challenging the Trump administration’s rollbacks of protections for endangered species.  The lawsuits, filed by 20 states and the District of Columbia, seek to reinstate rules that protect the habitat that endangered species depend on to survive.  Under President Donald Trump, federal agencies have […]
Alex Brown

Wak’a Garden

9 hours 43 minutes ago

Begin Again: Wak'a Garden is the second installment in Laumeier’s Begin Again series, honoring the Park’s 50-year history of collaborating with artists and supporting new commissions and exhibitions. The organic, amphitheater-shaped sculpture, built […]

The post Wak’a Garden appeared first on Explore St. Louis.

Myranda Levins

Trump, Kehoe post first negative approval ratings in new Missouri poll

9 hours 44 minutes ago
A new survey released Thursday shows more Missourians disapprove of President Donald Trump and Gov. Mike Kehoe’s job performance than approve. For Trump, it is the first negative approval rating in the six-year history of the St. Louis University/YouGov poll. For Kehoe, it is the first since he took office last year. Trump has lost […]
Rudi Keller

Trump administration aims to exclude many noncitizens from the census

10 hours 13 minutes ago
WASHINGTON — The Trump administration wants to overhaul the U.S. census to exclude noncitizens who don’t have a green card from the country’s next population count in 2030, according to a Wednesday notice in the Federal Register.  The document, which will officially be published Thursday, could mean major changes for how millions in federal funding […]
Ariana Figueroa

At midterm convention, Trump pledges cash to voters if Republicans hold Congress

10 hours 15 minutes ago
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump headlined the first night of the first Republican midterm convention Wednesday, seeking to rally his base ahead of the November elections and dangling a “Trump dividend” to voters if his party retains control of both congressional chambers. While the Republican National Committee’s two-day event — dubbed a “Trump-a-palooza” by party […]
Ashley Murray

Motorcyclist killed in crash in south St. Louis County

10 hours 16 minutes ago
ST. LOUIS COUNTY, Mo. - A motorcyclist was killed in a crash Wednesday afternoon in Sunset Hills. According to the Missouri State Highway Patrol (MSHP), the crash occurred shortly after 3 p.m. on S. Lindbergh Blvd at Denny Rd. It involved a Kawasaki Z5000 motorcycle and a Lincoln Aviator. The crash happened as the Lincoln [...]
Nick Gladney

St. Louis City SC ties Timbers 2-2 to extend unbeaten streak to 15

10 hours 39 minutes ago
PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — St. Louis City got two goals from newcomer Rafael Navarro, but Kristoffer Velde scored his second goal late in the second half on his 27th birthday to help the Portland Timbers earn a 2-2 draw on Wednesday night. St. Louis City (10-6-8) missed a shot at three points, but still managed [...]
Associated Press