a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

It sure looks like Jay Clayton lied to Congress about the NYT subpoenas

14 hours 19 minutes ago

U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton, who signed the now-withdrawn subpoenas for several New York Times reporters, testified in front of Congress last week as Donald Trump’s nominee for the director of national intelligence.

Under questioning from Sen. Michael Bennet, Clayton said that he followed the Trump administration’s media guidelines before signing the Times subpoenas. These guidelines include the following: “The government should have made all reasonable attempts to obtain the information, communications records, or business records from alternative sources.”

Clayton proactively called out this “all reasonable attempts” plank in his testimony:

“I’m confident that the procedures we have in place to protect the First Amendment and protect the freedom of the press … were followed. They depend on the facts and circumstances, how much time you have.

“Those matters include … ‘Are there other available sources for the information we seek?’ And have we sought that.”

He later repeated, “We followed the protocols” and “I want to assure this committee that … that concept of ‘least intrusive possible’ is front of mind for me.”

As we pointed out at the time, this was likely impossible. Given the Times’ story came out on a Wednesday and the subpoenas were issued on a Friday (after an hourslong White House meeting discussing the case with FBI Director Kash Patel), there was almost no way “all reasonable attempts” were made before the subpoenas were issued. These investigations usually take months.

It sure seemed like false testimony to us.

But on Friday, the Department of Justice itself seems to have confirmed that Clayton lied to Congress when he indicated they had pursued “all reasonable attempts” before issuing the subpoenas to the reporters.

In a court hearing in the Times subpoena case, a federal judge castigated government lawyers for an hour for making a multitude of errors when issuing the subpoenas, misleading the court, and not following the law, including the legal test in NY Times v. Gonzales that determines reporter’s privilege in the Second Circuit.

The judge specifically and repeatedly brought up the “all reasonable attempts” language, and how it was clear the government did not follow it:

Judge: I’m just asking you, am I wrong that the regulations and cases like Gonzales say that subpoenas issued to reporters and for the reporter’s records are not the first thing you do, they are the last thing you do? That is the reason why not obtainable from other sources is part of the Gonzales test. It’s the reason why in the regulation it specifically says that before you seek a subpoena, you need to make “all reasonable attempts to obtain the information from alternative sources.” It’s not a matter of classified or Rule 6 information. It’s a matter of just complying — basic compliance with the law.

The DOJ didn’t even attempt to argue they took any investigative steps before issuing the subpoenas. Instead, they claimed there was an “exception” to that rule that allowed them to bypass it entirely, which left the judge flabbergasted:

Judge: No, which language within this provision is clear that it’s an exception to the rule that’s stated two provisions above this that says, “The government should have made all reasonable attempts to obtain the information, communication records, or business records from alternative sources?” Maybe I’m missing it. You’re familiar with the regulations, so I just want to see where that is where it says except where it’s in this category, then subpoenas are the first thing you do, and you don’t do anything else. You go right to the subpoenas, and you don’t try to investigate otherwise, as Gonzales and the regulations otherwise provide.

The DOJ lawyer Sean Buckley responded:

Buckley: I would distinguish the language “should” in Section (4) from the language “must” in Section (c)(1) through (3). “Should” is advisory. And if the Attorney General authorizes the issuance of these subpoenas, it’s not a violation of the rule.

So DOJ is admitting: We did not actually do any investigation before issuing the subpoenas; we don’t have to, the rules only say we should. And the attorney general can just disregard them any time he wants.

The judge was not buying it, to say the least. He said he would quash the subpoenas unless the government withdrew them, and said if this was a civil case, he would be considering sanctions against the DOJ. The government ultimately withdrew them in disgrace.

You can read the full court transcript below.

It makes crystal clear that Clayton either lied to Congress that “all reasonable attempts” were made; or 2) he was purposefully misleading Congress by neglecting to mention that the Trump administration is manufacturing a magical exception to the DOJ guidelines that allows the attorney general to disregard them whenever he wants.

Clayton should be immediately called back to the Senate to answer for his seemingly false statement, and to tell lawmakers what other policies he believes agency heads don’t need to follow because they include the word “should.” And if you want to make your voice heard, use our action center to tell the Senate “No” on Clayton’s nomination.

Trevor Timm

Longevity Senior Living Offers Resources and Assistance for Seniors and Families

14 hours 26 minutes ago
GODFREY - Longevity Senior Living in Godfrey offers five levels of assisted living, and they’re happy to welcome you when the time is right. Located on Airport Road in Godfrey, Longevity Senior Living has a number of services that aim to help aging community members enjoy their golden years. Allison Combs, director of sales and marketing, noted that the senior living community is a chance for seniors to connect and get the medical assistance they need. “We are like a stationary

Two Charged After Altercation At Jersey County Fairgrounds

14 hours 32 minutes ago
JERSEYVILLE – Two local men were charged with battery in Jersey County last week following an alleged violent altercation at the Jersey County Fairgrounds the week prior. Lord Tyriq S. Hamilton, 22, of Alton, and Michael A. Malloy, 18, of Elsah, were both charged on July 22, 2026 in Jersey County court with one count each of aggravated battery in a public place, both Class 3 felonies. Charging documents state the two were involved “in an altercation and had to be pulled away from”

Flood of poll watchers, observers, monitors to descend on midterm voters

14 hours 47 minutes ago
WASHINGTON — Political party poll watchers are showing up more and more, usually outside polling places. They have a different mission than the nonpartisan election observers long regarded as bulwarks of credibility, and there’s concern that voters will be confused who’s there to influence them and who’s there to protect them. The growing presence of […]
David Lightman

Wrong-Way Crash Leaves 2 Dead, 1 Injured

14 hours 58 minutes ago
ST. LOUIS - Two drivers were killed, and a passenger was critically injured late Sunday, July 26, 2026, in a wrong-way crash on Interstate 64 at Jefferson Avenue, where investigators say a Mazda CX entered the highway from Forest Park Parkway and traveled in the wrong direction before colliding with a Ford Explorer. The St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department's Accident Reconstruction Unit is investigating the crash, which happened around 11:40 p.m. Sunday, July 26, 2026, according to a preliminary

Calhoun County Sheriff's Office Introduces New Deputy Jeremy Gwartney

15 hours 4 minutes ago
HARDIN - The Calhoun County Sheriff’s Office announced July 26 that Jeremy Gwartney has joined the department as its newest deputy sheriff after being sworn in by Judge Charles H.W. Burch and later accepting a full-time role following an intergovernmental agreement signed July 1, 2026, with the Village of Hardin. Gwartney was initially hired as a part-time deputy, according to the sheriff’s office. He accepted a full-time position with the Calhoun County Sheriff’s Office after

Why Summer Often Brings Out People's Most Creative Ideas

15 hours 13 minutes ago
Some of the best ideas arrive when we stop trying so hard to have them. That is one reason summer often feels unusually creative. People sketch more, start side projects, rearrange their homes, write in notebooks, and suddenly feel drawn to music, cooking, photography, or travel planning. It is not magic. It is a mix of lighter routines, more sensory experiences, and a mental shift that gives the brain room to connect ideas in fresh ways. Why creativity often feels easier in summer Creativity

Trump Withheld Funds From Democratic States, Pritzker Demands Release

15 hours 17 minutes ago
CHICAGO – The Trump administration just admitted in a federal court filing to canceling federal grants to states solely because they did not vote for Donald Trump in 2024. In 2025, the Trump administration canceled $583 million in federal grant funding intended for Illinois organizations that would have gone toward lowering energy costs, strengthening grid reliability, and creating energy jobs. This is a politically motivated attack on Illinois working families already struggling

Why Fairs and Festivals Hold Such a Powerful Pull for People

15 hours 17 minutes ago
A fair can turn a parking lot into a place people talk about for years. Add music, bright lights, food stands, and a crowd moving with the same excited energy, and even ordinary space starts to feel special. That shift helps explain why humans love fairs and festivals. These events are not just about rides, concerts, parades, or holiday traditions. They give people something many parts of daily life do not: shared excitement. For a few hours or days, normal routines loosen. Strangers stand shoulde

Duckworth, Schakowsky Lead Bill To Provide Accessible Housing For Veterans, Individuals With Disabilities And Aging Americans

15 hours 22 minutes ago
WASHINGTON, D.C. – U.S. Senator Tammy Duckworth (D-IL) and Representative Jan Schakowsky (D-IL-09) today reintroduced bicameral legislation to reduce housing accessibility barriers and improve mobility for people with disabilities. The Eleanor Smith Inclusive Home Design Act would require all newly constructed single-family homes, townhouses and multi-level dwelling units built with federal funding include at least one accessible (or “zero step”) entrance into the home,