a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

Declassify RT records so the public can vet administration's claims

1 year 3 months ago

RT’s office in Moscow. The Biden administration recently declassified intelligence findings to support new sanctions against RT, but did not declassify the documents themselves.

Iliya Pitalev/Sputnik via AP Photo

The Biden administration last week declassified information alleging that Russian state media outlet RT has, in the words of Secretary of State Antony Blinken, “engaged in covert information and influence operations and military procurement” on behalf of the Kremlin. The newly public information, released to bolster new sanctions against the news organization, did not include declassification of the underlying documents — only their findings.

This is the latest example of the Biden administration strategically declassifying U.S. secrets. It is a good initiative — and one that would be strengthened by declassifying the records themselves.

Failing to do so is a missed opportunity in the RT case for two reasons.

The first is that declassifying the records could help shore up support for a move that raises serious First Amendment concerns or questions of cherry-picked evidence. Releasing the underlying documents could also empower press advocates and other potential skeptics to mount an informed opposition to the administration’s efforts. That might not further the administration’s strategic goals but it is (or it should be) the American way.

Charges of military procurement and “information and influence operations” sound bad, but such allegations — and the documents they are based on — must be analyzed and challenged. Press freedom advocates have often been worried about these types of cases because it puts state-funded journalists in countries like Russia at risk of serious retaliation. Vetting the evidence is important for this reason, as is remembering that the documents in and of themselves should not be taken as the unbiased truth. They are pieces of evidence recording oftentimes subjective interpretations of events.

Americans should know exactly what kind of “information and influence” operations by state-sponsored media the government deems worthy of punishment. All state media outlets, including our own, seek to advance the interests of the government in some way, and Americans are constitutionally entitled to consume foreign propaganda if they so choose. If RT's alleged conduct is not starkly different from what other government media outlets do, then the investigation puts outlets worldwide at risk of retaliation.

Cherry picking evidence is also not an abstract concern. In 2003, for example, the Bush administration used bad intelligence from a debunked informant, codenamed Curveball, to justify its long-standing plan to invade Iraq. And the Biden administration has previously shown willingness to overlook free speech concerns when it contends that national security is imperiled without sharing any underlying evidence, including by supporting banning TikTok and prosecuting WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange.

The second reason is that declassifying documentary evidence is important during a presidential election season where one candidate has repeatedly made baseless and threatening claims about the press. Showing the public the details of Russian state media’s abuses — assuming the documents do so — would undercut politicians’ false equivalencies to conduct by American news outlets they don’t like.

The Biden administration’s secret-sharing program

The RT declassification is not the first time the administration has selectively downgraded classified information.

The Biden administration has repeatedly declassified intelligence on Russian activities in Ukraine. The effort was deemed so successful at countering Russian disinformation that it prompted the White House to build a “broad program to share secrets when it serves strategic goals,” according to a deep dive by Time magazine into the program. And while this approach to declassification is not new, the Biden administration’s method is unique both because it is a formal process that is centralized in the White House (as opposed to the intelligence community), and is used regularly, sometimes multiple times a day.

This effort has released information that helped de-escalate Serbian military buildup along the Kosovo border; undercut Chinese attempts to retaliate against the U.S. for then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan; and persuaded Iran to stop supporting Houthi attacks on merchant ships in the Red Sea.

The National Security Council leads the program, but individual agencies like the CIA make the ultimate decision about whether information is declassified. This presents a challenge because “Intelligence officers who had classified secrets to begin with were loath to declassify them,” the Time report found. To address agency concerns, the Biden administration does not ask for full or finished reports, opting instead to ask for individual facts or data points. It then usually combines the declassified intelligence with open-source information for release to the press.

Show your work

White House-led declassification efforts should continue, but the administration itself has concluded that the program will only succeed if it has “enough credibility to overcome the U.S. history of bad intelligence and propaganda abuse.”

The solution is straightforward. Declassify the documents themselves. This would rebuff arguments that the intelligence being presented is cherry picked or weak.

The next time — and I do hope there is a next time — the administration strategically declassifies information, it should show its work and let the public see the documents. This won’t solve the crisis of overclassification, and declassifying strategically important documents should not take precedence over releasing records that reveal uncomfortable or politically inconvenient truths, but it is a step in the right direction.

Lauren Harper

Coach Roustio Reads To Prather Kindergarten Students On Pirate Day and Bus Safety Drills

1 year 3 months ago
GRANITE CITY – Prather Kindergarten Center welcomed a special guest Thursday to celebrate International Talk Like a Pirate Day and to partake in bus safety drills. Granite City High School head football coach Steve Roustio read to students during an assembly and then joined them on a school bus to discuss bus safety rules and participate in evacuation drills. The event aimed to combine fun with education, ensuring that young students understand the importance of bus safety. The event was part of a broader initiative by Granite City School District 9 to ensure student safety through engaging and educational activities.

Continue Reading

Trailblazing K-9 Bonnie Of St. Charles County Police Retires After Eight Years of Service

1 year 3 months ago
ST. CHARLES CO. - Bonnie, a St. Charles County K-9 Electronic Detection Dog, and now School Resource Officer K-9, is calling it quits after eight years of catching sex offenders and human traffickers that used electronic devices to commit their crimes. The St. Charles County Police Department is celebrating Bonnie’s eight years of faithful service September 20th at 10 a.m. with a retirement ceremony, where his many accomplishments will be acknowledged and rewarded with baskets of gifts and treats from local pet supporters. The ceremony will be at the St. Charles County Police Department (101 Sheriff Dierker Ct., O’Fallon, MO). Bonnie, a 10-year-old Labrador Retriever, began her career in 2016 with an initial 5-week training in Electronic Storage Detection (ESD) with the Connecticut State Police K-9 Unit. The Connecticut State Police K-9 Unit was the first in the world to train K-9’s in detection of ESD’s. Upon Bonnie’s completion of training in April 2016,

Continue Reading

The Fed says its long-awaited rate cut is apolitical, even close to the presidential election

1 year 3 months ago
The Federal Reserve’s first key interest rate cut in four years coincides with another major four-year event: the homestretch of the presidential election. Fed Chair Jerome Powell downplayed the central bank’s role in the race between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump on Wednesday, in announcing the half-percentage point cut in its […]
Casey Quinlan

Lilli Ray: A Standout Since Freshman Year Is A Midwest Members Credit Union Female Athlete Of Month

1 year 3 months ago
ROXANA – Lilli Ray, a standout athlete at Roxana High School, has been recognized as the Midwest Members Credit Union Female Athlete of the Month. Ray, who has excelled in both softball and volleyball, batted .347 this past season under the guidance of Coach Wade Stahlhut. She recorded 25 hits and 18 RBIs in 20 games, according to Max Preps. Ray's athletic prowess extends beyond the softball field. In the fall, she serves as a defensive specialist for the Roxana girls' volleyball team. Coach Stahlhut has praised her consistent performance since her freshman year, noting her hard work and dedication. "We expect the same growth in her in the 2025 season," Stahlhut said. "We are very fortunate to have her. She is extremely hard-working and has some of the same characteristics as our other girls." Ray's contributions to her teams are not limited to her offensive skills. Coach Stahlhut emphasized her defensive capabilities, highlighting her well-rounded talent. The recognition

Continue Reading

"Best Year Ever": Belleville's Art on the Square Announces New Co-Directors

1 year 3 months ago
BELLEVILLE - The beloved Belleville Art on the Square foundation and festival has two new co-directors. The Art on the Square organization announced that Rebecca Boyer and Karl Gilpin will step into the roles previously held by Carol Bartle and Stephanie Dorris. The two new directors will see the organization through its 2025 festival on May 16–18, 2025. “It is exciting,” Boyer said. “Karl and I know there’s a lot that needs to be done, but we have a great team. They’re able and willing to help us pull this off.” Gilpin shared that Art on the Square was in a “precarious situation.” It was unclear whether the festival would happen in 2025. He encouraged Boyer to take on the director role. When she said she was too busy for the position, they agreed to come on as co-directors and collaborate to make the festival a success. “We started talking about it. I was like, well, we can’t let this thing die,” Gilpi

Continue Reading

Making an IMPACT Foundation Holds Third Annual Sporting Clay Classic

1 year 3 months ago
The Making an IMPACT Foundation, a charitable foundation established by IMPACT Strategies of Fairview Heights, IL, held its third annual Sporting Clay Classic on September 13. The event, held at NILO Farms in Brighton, IL, raised more than $20,000 for Hoyleton Youth and Family Services. IMPACT has much appreciation for our 20 subcontractor business partners […]
Dede Hance

Missouri Rural Roads & Bridges Among Most Deteriorated in U.S.

1 year 3 months ago
America’s rural transportation system is in need of repairs and modernization to support economic growth and improve traffic safety, but the US faces a $198 billion backlog in funding for needed repairs and improvements to its rural transportation system. This is according to a new report released today by TRIP, a national transportation research nonprofit. The […]
Dede Hance