a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

Journalists must be able to cover America’s incarcerated

1 year 8 months ago

San Diego Central Jail

San Diego County Sheriff's Department

When sources aren’t allowed to talk, journalists turn to public records. And when journalists can’t obtain public records, they look for insiders. But when all are unavailable, it becomes exceedingly difficult for journalists to report the news. 

That’s the situation often encountered by journalists looking to investigate U.S. jails and prisons and the challenges facing America’s over 2 million incarcerated people.

If journalists try to talk to prison officials, they’re routed to public information officers, who give them little besides official PR. If they try to request public documents, the government stalls indefinitely with bogus claims that the documents are exempted from open records laws. And good luck talking to incarcerated people themselves. In some states, it’s outright illegal for them to speak to the press. In others, they face “relentless retaliation” for attempting to bring publicity to prison conditions. 

Freedom of the Press Foundation (FPF) recently joined a legal brief that seeks to address the records problem. A group of news outlets successfully sought access to sealed records about deaths and serious injuries at jails in San Diego County, California, from the Sheriff’s Department Critical Incident Review Board, or CIRB. 

The county appealed in hopes of maintaining secrecy, claiming that transparency would undermine the ability of officials to communicate candidly.

But the brief responded that “CIRB investigations and related documents have been shielded from the public for over twenty years. … Given the increasing number of deaths, that secrecy hardly seems to be facilitating any meaningful change.”  

That’s exactly right. Whenever the government claims that a lack of transparency somehow benefits the public, courts should be extremely skeptical and demand proof, not speculation. Virtually every time — whether in cases involving jails and prisons or national defense — the real reason for secrecy is that officials don’t want to be embarrassed.

The same applies to restrictions on officials’ or incarcerated people’s communications with the press. The former restriction violates the First Amendment rights of government employees, in addition to depriving the public of important information. To justify the latter restriction, officials often say that violent crime victims shouldn’t have to hear from their assailants in the media — a constitutionally inadequate excuse even putting aside that, for some reason, those policies are rarely limited to violent criminals. 

Recent lawsuits in Pennsylvania and South Carolina challenge restrictions on media access to prison employees and incarcerated people, respectively. It’ll likely take many more lawsuits and much more advocacy, but hopefully, sometime soon, Americans will be able to see for themselves the inner workings of the world’s largest system of mass incarceration. 

You can read the brief in the San Diego case here or below.

Seth Stern

Remembering Colin Murphy, journalist, mentor and LGBTQ activist

1 year 8 months ago
Colin Murphy, co-founder of Boom Magazine — a queer publication focusing on the bi-state region — has died after a two-year battle with cancer. He was 53 years old. He is remembered for his positivity and mentorship despite the adversity he faced as a gay man with HIV as well as his passion for providing a news platform by and for queer people in the bi-state region.

KDHX Elections Have Just 1 Candidate, Hand-Picked by the Board

1 year 8 months ago
As KDHX (88.1 FM) once again sticks out its hands and asks for money during its pledge drive this week, the ongoing behind-the-scenes drama sees the station's leadership continuing to shut out its staff of volunteer DJs from the organization's governance. For the upcoming vote for a new board member, the board put forth only one name — leading critics to label the election as "a mockery of democracy" that "flouts the [KDHX parent company] Double Helix bylaws." Caryn Haddix is the lone candidate on the ballot for this week's election, for which all active volunteers, also known as associates, are eligible to vote.
Daniel Hill

To You, I Go

1 year 8 months ago

To You, I Go (2023) is Jessica Page’s visual love letter to St. Louis. Although St. Louis is rarely romanticized, Page aims to showcase the softest purest side of her […]

The post To You, I Go appeared first on Explore St. Louis.

Rachel Huffman

Techdirt Podcast Episode 382: Checking In On Bluesky With Jay Graber

1 year 8 months ago
Anyone who follows Techdirt knows we’re very interested in the progress of Bluesky, the decentralized social network that embraces our concept of protocols over platforms. Bluesky recently ended its invite-only beta and opened its doors to the public, so it seems like a great time for a check-in, and who better to check in with […]
Leigh Beadon