a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

Lights, camera, national security crisis!

2 months ago

President Donald Trump’s recent announcement that he plans to impose a 100% tariff on movies made outside the United States has created more confusion than the ending of “Inception.”

But there are two important questions no one seems to be asking. Namely: What in the world is Trump talking about when he claims that making movies outside the U.S. is a national security threat? And why should anyone — let alone any court — ever take this administration seriously again when it claims national security is endangered?

In his Truth Social post about the movie tariff, Trump makes two main arguments (if you can call them that) based on national security. Both are completely unjustified.

First, he claims that the U.S. filmmaking industry is being “devastated” by other nations trying to lure moviemakers to their countries. “This is a concerted effort by other Nations,” he wrote, “and, therefore, a National Security threat.”

But economic harm doesn’t necessarily mean national security harm. While it may mean less money for parts of the American film industry, filming “Mission: Impossible — The Final Reckoning” in Norway doesn’t make us less secure. Plus tariffs are a nonsensical way to safeguard national security — foreign adversaries can attack us as long as they pay a fine?

Also, some movies simply must be made outside the U.S. The last three winners of the Academy Award for Best Documentary — “No Other Land,” “20 Days in Mariupol,” and “Navalny” — were all filmed outside the U.S. because they told stories from outside the U.S. Slapping movies like those with tariffs will make them more expensive and less likely to be made or shown in the U.S., depriving Americans of important perspectives about what’s going on in the rest of the world.

Trump’s second national security argument is that foreign-made movies are “in addition to everything else, messaging and propaganda!” It’s a rich claim, given Hollywood’s history exporting U.S. propaganda and present-day examples of links between U.S. films and U.S. interests.

Trump’s national security claims are just like the movies: all smoke and mirrors.

It’s also essentially the same argument used by both Trump and former President Joe Biden to justify the TikTok ban, i.e., that foreign-made mass media threatens national security by exposing Americans to foreign propaganda. The Supreme Court got it wrong in upholding the TikTok ban. But it applied a lower level of First Amendment scrutiny to the law based on TikTok’s special characteristics, including its collection of vast amounts of data. That leniency shouldn’t apply to a tariff or other law that burdens speech simply because it’s created outside the U.S.

And have you noticed that we haven’t heard much about the app’s supposed massive threat to our national security lately? That’s because Trump no longer wants to ban it, now that he’s amassed millions of followers there and met with the Republican megadonor who also owns part of TikTok. The social platform continues to operate in the U.S., and somehow our national security has remained intact.

This all goes to show that, just like many other purported national security concerns, “propaganda” is simply a convenient argument for an administration to invoke when it suits its purposes and to discard when it doesn’t. Other administrations have also invoked national security when convenient to avoid hard questions or uncomfortable truths. But Trump is taking it to a whole new level.

According to Trump, almost anything can be justified by citing national security: deporting students who write op-eds critical of Israel in college newspapers, refusing to tell a judge what time U.S. planes carrying migrants took off, even attacking Greenland.

Most concerningly for journalists and their sources, the Trump administration has also launched numerous leak investigations and rolled back protections for journalists’ records, all in the name of national security. But documents released to Freedom of the Press Foundation (FPF) via the Freedom of Information Act show that the reporting the administration cited to justify its crackdown on leaks to reporters did not threaten our national security as claimed.

Instead, they exposed that the administration’s justification for invoking the Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelans to El Salvador was rejected by American intelligence agencies. When Trump claims to be protecting the homeland from foreign adversaries he is often actually protecting his own false narratives from domestic scrutiny.

Many of these national security claims will be challenged in court, and all of them should be weighed skeptically in the court of public opinion. Given this administration’s track record, judges and the public must remember that Trump’s national security claims are just like the movies: all smoke and mirrors.

Caitlin Vogus

STL Health Dept. checks visitors' log at aquarium for measles exposure

2 months ago
St. Louis health leaders on Tuesday provided new details about the potential measles exposure at the St. Louis Aquarium last week. Staff at the city health department are looking over sign-in sheets at the aquarium and notifying anyone who may have been exposed to the measles, including a group of children.
Mallory Thomas

Missouri Senate passes bill to fund sheriffs’ retirement system

2 months ago
A bill to fund pensions for Missouri sheriffs from new fees on court documents and a slice of the money the state pays counties to house prisoners passed the state Senate on a nearly unanimous vote Tuesday, potentially rescuing a retirement system that voters refused to support at the ballot in November. Last year, lawmakers […]
Rudi Keller

Future Teachers Celebrated at Civic Memorial's Signing Ceremony

2 months ago
BETHALTO - Bethalto’s future teachers were honored at the annual Educators Rising signing ceremony at Civic Memorial High School. On Tuesday, May 6, 2025, this ceremony recognized the graduating students who have committed to studying education in college. Angie Neilson, who oversees the Education Pathway program at Civic Memorial, explained that the seniors have had the opportunity to shadow Bethalto teachers and engage with younger students, and she is incredibly proud of them. “I could teach them out of a textbook, which I do a little bit of that, but they push out into class and they’re teaching lessons and they’re out at recess and they’re helping during lunch, because that’s where they fall in love with it,” Neilson explained. “This was our biggest class of future teachers, so we thought about doing a signing to recognize them, because the hope is that they do come back here and teach.” The honored students included

Continue Reading

Real ID rules for domestic flights begins Wednesday

2 months ago
On May 7, the new federal Real ID requirements for flying domestically in the United States begin, and the Department of Homeland Security's website directs individuals to the DMV's page for a list of required identifiers.
Patrick Clark

Belleville, Caseyville, Fairview Heights, Batchtown, Troy, Females Named Outstanding Graduating Girl Scouts

2 months ago
GLEN CARBON – Girl Scouts of Southern Illinois is pleased to announce that twelve girls were named Outstanding Graduating Girl Scouts at the annual Recognition of Excellence ceremony on Sunday, April 27. Outstanding Graduating Girl Scouts are awarded a scholarship for demonstrating their extraordinary leadership in the Girl Scout Movement, in school, and in their communities. Along with sharing their achievements and contributions, girls who apply for the scholarship submit an essay entitled “What Girl Scouts Means to Me” along with a reference letter. Outstanding Graduating Girl Scout Scholarships are funded from proceeds from the annual United We Lead Gala. Congratulations to this year’s Outstanding Graduating Girl Scouts! Kaylee Asher Belleville, Illinois Troop #74 Kyleigh Bagby Belleville, Illinois Troop #74 Riley Baldwin Fairview Heights, Illinois Troop #177 Violet Barnett Troy, Illinois Troop #578 Olivia Brodbeck Batchtown, Illinois

Continue Reading