a Better Bubble™

Aggregator

Edwardsville Residents Speak For, Against Overnight Warming Location, Mayor Gives Update

2 years 10 months ago
EDWARDSVILLE - Edwardsville residents at Tuesday’s City Council meeting shared a range of perspectives for and against the Overnight Warming Location (OWL) operating out of the First Baptist Church at 534 St. Louis Street in Edwardsville, following an announcement from Mayor Art Risavy. Risavy announced at the meeting that he has asked his staff to suspend a citation that was issued against the church for operating as a warming location without a special use permit. He said the city never planned to shut the center down and no fines were ever imposed or collected. “I’ve been working with urgency to try to resolve our issues with the Overnight Warming Location at First Baptist Church,” Mayor Risavy said. “It was never our intent to prevent it from operating, particularly at a time of such dangerous weather conditions - and please know, there were no fines ever imposed or collected.” Risavy’s account of events varies greatly from

Continue Reading

Mind blowing: The CDC is publishing maternal mortality figures it knows are wildly wrong

2 years 10 months ago
As you know, the maternal mortality rate has been increasing steadily in the US. Except, as Noah Smith informs us, it turns out it hasn't. This is a bizarre story. In 2003 the standard US death certificate added a pregnancy checkbox. As more and more states adopted the new certificate, reports of maternal mortality went ...continue reading "Mind blowing: The CDC is publishing maternal mortality figures it knows are wildly wrong"
Kevin Drum

Blaine Luetkemeyer (2024)

2 years 10 months ago
U.S. Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer threw a bit of a curve to Missouri’s already crowded primary season when he announced he wouldn’t run for another term. The St. Elizabeth Republican hasn’t been shy about expressing his disdain about high-profile infighting within his party, culminating in Kevin McCarthy’s ouster as speaker and a marathon melodrama to pick his replacement. But Luetkemeyer stressed his decision to retire after 16 years is based on a legitimate desire to stop working. “I’m going to be 72 years old in May. And so people ask me about my health … is that the reason I'm retiring? I say: ‘No, my health is good. That's why I'm retiring,’” Luetkemeyer said in a wide-ranging interview.

Maplewood History: The Contents of a Privy – Part One

2 years 10 months ago
If you don’t know what a privy is, much less the contents of one, well, this should be an eyeopener.  In this case the privy was, a real long time ago, an outhouse in the backyard of Maplewood’s oldest home…Woodside.  If that seems kind of icky, it was back then.  But the microbes have done […]
Doug Houser

Government gag rules muzzle journalists’ sources

2 years 10 months ago

Rules that silence public employees can also stymie journalists from reporting newsworthy information.

As the COVID-19 pandemic raged in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, journalist Brittany Hailer reported story after story about its impacts on the county jail, including the deaths of incarcerated people, shortages of correctional and medical staff, the prolonged use of 23-hour lockdowns, and unsafe and unsanitary kitchen practices.

Hailer’s news stories quote many sources: incarcerated people, their family members, the jail spokesperson and warden, and more. But the voices of rank-and-file jail employees are nowhere to be found, at least on the record. The reason? Jail policies that prevent them from speaking to the press.

Government gag rules are policies that prohibit public employees from speaking to journalists about their work or require them to seek approval from higher-ups first. Gag rules often mean that journalists seeking firsthand information must go through a high-ranking official or public information officer who often lacks the on-the-ground knowledge reporters need. And even if PIOs do know some information about a news story, they can be more concerned with protecting the government’s image than giving a reporter the facts.

Last summer, Hailer became the first journalist in the country to file a lawsuit testing government gag rules, when she brought a First Amendment challenge to the Allegheny County Jail’s policies. Hailer’s lawsuit, which remains pending, claims there are several jail workers who want to speak out about unreported problems, but can’t because of the gag rules.

She argues that the policies violate her First Amendment right to speak to sources who want to talk to her. Hailer also argues that they violate the First Amendment rights of the jail employees by prohibiting them from speaking as private citizens on matters of public concern.

The Supreme Court has said that employees don’t surrender all of their First Amendment rights simply because they take a government paycheck. Based on that precedent and other decisions disfavoring “prior restraints” on employee speech, numerous courts have ruled in favor of government employees who have challenged policies requiring them to seek preapproval before speaking about their work.

Despite that, government gag rules remain abundant, either because agencies don’t know about this precedent or just don’t care, especially if their individual policy doesn’t face a court challenge.

While in the past, government employees may have felt relatively free to speak to reporters, in recent years, censorship by PIO has become the norm. The Society for Professional Journalists has long documented and decried these rules as “an effective form of censorship by which powerful entities keep the public ignorant about what impacts them.”

Some journalists say that they don’t need government sources to speak on the record to effectively report the news, and it’s true that there are other ways to find and report information. But government employees are important sources for many journalists, and rules muzzling them undoubtedly make reporting harder. When government sources can’t confirm information on the record or are afraid to speak even off the record, there’s sure to be important information that never makes it to the public.

Plus, government agencies are making it harder and harder for even the most diligent reporters to find other sources of information. Freedom of Information Act backlogs continue to grow. Courts close trials to the public or otherwise limit public access. Officials target journalists for uncovering information online, even when the government puts it on the internet itself. Excessive secrecy, combined with gag rules, leaves reporters with fewer and fewer avenues to report about what’s truly happening within all levels and branches of government.

Gag rules also help the government manipulate for political reasons the information journalists and the public receive. The Trump administration stopped the Environmental Protection Agency and other federal agencies from talking to the press about climate change. During the height of the pandemic, Trump also prevented employees of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention from talking to the press, potentially endangering people’s lives.

But a government policy gagging employees doesn’t have to be part of a nefarious plot to cover up wrongdoing for it to interfere with the public’s access to information. These rules often prevent even basic information about how government employees do their jobs from getting out. For example, gag rules have forbidden everything from a police officer talking about the impact of responding to a school shooting to a state scientist explaining his research on birds.

Hailer’s legal challenge will be an important step in establishing that journalists have a First Amendment right to speak to willing government employees. But it shouldn’t take a legal battle for the Allegheny County Jail and other government offices to understand why gag rules are unconstitutional and wrong. The point is simple: The people who work for the public should be allowed to speak to the public.

Caitlin Vogus